In 1900 Pearl V Abbey b. 8/1888 PA was living in the Town of Scio, Allegany, NY in the house of George W Smith b. 8/1841 NY, farmer, and Elma Smith b. 10/1846 NY. In 1910 Pearl Abbey 21 b. PA, no occupation, was a lodger in the Brainard household in Warren, Trumbull, Ohio. Obituary of Frances Puckett indicates a daughter Pearl; Abbey connection through letter of Charles & Hazel Cox. Mrs. Elmer Cox of Ravenna, Ohio was named as a niece in the obituary of Pitt Abbey.
From The Haine Book 2000 (http://www.haine.org.uk/Haine_Book_2000.pdf):
On Dr. William Haine: ìWilliam later sold this practice and moved his family to 836 Adams Street in Warren Ohio. Dr William traveled extensively, leaving his large family on Adams Street for long periods of time. Due to hard times for the family and to make ends meet, Cornelia and children took in borders. Among them was one young lady, Pearl Abbey, who lived with the Brainards on Atlantic Street, but took her meals with the Haine family. Pearl became close friends with their cousins, the four Cox sisters, then eventually their brother Elmer Cox, whom she married in 1911."

Thanks for looking at my file. I hope you cite me as a reference if you use anything in this file!